Special issue: Indian Ocean tsunami response - February 2005

In this issue


The Asia and the Pacific region has made great progress towards reaching the Millennium Development Goals. Democratic governance, enabling policy frameworks and effective implementation of poverty reduction programmes have contributed to this success.

But the tsunami of 26 December 2004 demonstrates just how vulnerable poor rural women, children and men continue to be. Within a few hours, the livelihoods of hundreds of thousands of rural poor people were wiped out. This disaster struck shortly after rural poor people had to deal with the impact of the 1997 Asian financial crisis.

For improvements in the lives and livelihoods of rural poor people to be sustainable, we must maintain a constant commitment to ensuring that they are less vulnerable to risks and shocks such as the tsunami.

IFAD's response to the tsunami will focus on the needs expressed by rural communities themselves. It will address the requirements for long-term recovery, including private and public asset rehabilitation, and will harness the energies of local stakeholders under the leadership of governments.

Thomas Elhaut, Director, Asia and the Pacific Division

Back to top


IFAD commits to mobilize initial US$ 100 million for reconstruction in tsunami-devastated communities

IFAD is committed to mobilizing an initial US$100 million in new resources for countries affected by the tsunami. The funds will be deployed through new and established projects and programmes and through new regional, country and community grants. IFAD is participating in joint needs assessments in Indonesia and Sri Lanka with the World Bank, the Asian Development Bank (ADB) and other partners. In the Maldives, IFAD is undertaking a Tsunami Response Needs Assessment Mission in partnership with the FAO Investment Centre. Based on the results of these assessments, IFAD will develop special resource mobilization mechanisms for addressing the long-term needs of affected communities.

Back to top


Country response

India

"The only way to help these people who've suffered so much is to give them their livelihoods back as quickly as we can."
Vivek Harinarain, Secretary, Government of Tamil Nadu, Information Technology Division

Tidal waves crashed into eastern and southern India , affecting a total area of 2,200 km of coastal land in the states of Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Orissa, Kerala and the Union Territories of Pondicherry and Andaman and Nicobar. The government estimates that the tsunami's impact includes:

  • 10,714 dead
  • about 157,393 dwelling units damaged by the tidal waves
  • 11,827 hectares of crops damaged
  • about 2,000 fishing boats and about 48,000 other items of fishing equipment lost in the state of Andhra Pradesh
  • about 300,000 fishers lost their jobs

According to the ADB, the macro impact of the tsunami will be minimal due to India's large economy. However, the number of poor people in the country could increase by 645,000.

IFAD's response

IFAD is exploring how to improve the ability of coastal communities to cope with crisis by developing a livelihood security programme. Options could include:

  • community-based coastal resources management
  • livelihood security projects
  • introduction of appropriate financial instruments

Any investment ideas that emerge from the needs assessment exercise now underway will be discussed with both the central government and the state governments concerned.

IFAD's country strategy for India has already identified a high incidence of poverty in coastal fisher communities in Tamil Nadu. Pollution, degradation of the coastal environment, depletion of fish stocks and displacement due to sea erosion was already deteriorating the quality of life in these communities before the tsunami struck.

Back to top


Indonesia

"We were fishermen and lived right on the beach. I lost my entire family, all my assets, everything… We need help to build houses, wherever we go. We will need capital to rebuild our businesses."
Fisherman in temporary camp, Banda Aceh, The Consultative Group on Indonesia , 2005

Indonesia is the worst affected country in the region. Situated 250 km from the epicentre of the massive earthquake, the province of Banda Aceh , followed by the North Sumatra Province, suffered the most physical damage and heaviest human casualties. The most significant impact as estimated by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and the Ministry of Agriculture (MOA) includes:

  • about 166,320 dead
  • 703,518 displaced
  • many farmers lost their tools, equipment and livestock
  • fields levelled, water reservoirs destroyed, and irrigation and drainage facilities destroyed in an area estimated at 39,500 ha
  • crops on more than 50,000 ha of land damaged and some agricultural land permanently lost
  • about 70 per cent of the small-scale fishing fleet destroyed in Nanggroe Aceh Darussalam Province , where small-scale fishery was the main economic activity

While the overall Indonesian economy is not expected to be greatly affected by the tsunami, its impact on local poverty levels may be substantial. The ADB estimates that more than one million people will be pushed into poverty.

IFAD's response

  • Reallocate funds from the ongoing Rural Income Generation Project to a new project in the disaster-affected areas. In collaboration with the Bank Rakyat Indonesia , the project will give support to affected communities to:
    • access mainstream financial services
    • rehabilitate livelihoods through training and grants
  • Expand the geographical area of the Rural Empowerment and Agricultural Development Programme in Central Sulawesi to the Aceh province. Respecting priorities expressed by local people, the programme will aim to establish community-managed development funds for infrastructure development and income generation.
  • Design and implement a new programme to immediately rehabilitate the livelihoods of the most vulnerable people, such as women-headed and destitute households.
  • Explore the possibility of using grant financing through other development partners to fund the proposed operations.
  • Respond to requests by the Government of Indonesia for support in seeking debt service relief from public creditors. IFAD could also explore the possibility of debt service relief for 2005 from its own loan to Indonesia (approximately US$25.4 million).

Back to top


Maldives

"I spent the morning on Mami Gili. It's an island about 120 km from Male. After the tsunami, the people there invited the inhabitants of another small island, Madi Fushi, to stay with them. Madi Fushi has about 130 people and all their houses were destroyed. They came up with this idea: couldn't they stay on Mami Gili?"

"Today was the foundation-laying ceremony for the houses we're going to build there for the displaced people."
Ismail Shafeeu, Minister for Defence and National Security, Maldives , 25 January 2005

The magnitude and scale of the disaster relative to the size and population of the Maldives is unprecedented in living memory. The tsunami inundated the entire country. The most significant impact of the tsunami in the Maldives , as estimated by FAO, the World Health Organization (WHO), the United Nations (UN) and ADB include:

  • 83 dead
  • more than 12,000 displaced
  • the entire infrastructure destroyed in 13 out of 202 inhabited islands
  • 30 islands with no safe drinking water
  • 50 per cent of agricultural land completely destroyed, affecting food security and income generation in rural areas
  • 120 fishing vessels destroyed, badly damaged or lost and 50 vessels partially damaged. Given that about 20 per cent of the population depends on fishing for its livelihood, the damage is significant.

IFAD's response

  • Build on activities of the recently closed Southern Atolls Development Project. Under exceptional circumstances, the project activities could be allowed to continue in the tsunami-affected areas of the southern atolls.
  • Design and implement a new Tsunami Disaster Mitigation Programme that will focus on fisheries and atolls resource management and will cover most of the affected atolls. The programme would respond to the tsunami response needs assessment being carried out by the Government and its partners.
  • Explore possibilities for partnership with other key agencies and organizations active in the country.
  • Provide a small country grant to deal with relevant policy issues that are emerging as a result of the tsunami disaster.

IFAD has earmarked US$4.5 million for these activities, of which US$500,000 will be grants and US$4 million will be in loans.

Back to top


Sri Lanka

"We have received a massive quantity of relief goods and aid from several foreign countries, with which we can rebuild this country. To this end, we should enter the next stage of operations with clear vision."
Thinakaran, Sri Lanka as quoted by BBC South Asia, 26 January 2005

In Sri Lanka , the tsunami caused devastation on the north-east, east, south and south-west coastal areas. At least 1 million people were directly affected, with infrastructure partially or fully destroyed as far as two kilometres inland. Some of the most significant losses, as reported by WHO, FAO and UNDP, include:

  • 38,195 dead
  • 2,175 hectares of paddy and 1,708 hectares of other crops lost in the country's large paddy growing areas, wiping out one third of the production in the main cropping season
  • destroyed water reservoirs, bunds and dikes, irrigation and drainage facilities, including the infrastructure protecting against sea intrusion
  • lost farming capital, including livestock, hand tools and other farming implements
  • about 18,500 fishing vessels lost or damaged, representing over 80 per cent of the fishing fleet in the affected areas. Fishing was a primary source of livelihood for much of the population hit by the tsunami, providing direct employment to about 250,000 people.

ADB estimates that the country's economy, together with the Maldives , will be among the most affected given that both countries depend on tourism, which is expected to decrease. The devastating effects of the tsunami could push about 250,000 more people into poverty.

IFAD's response:

  • Include new activities under the Dry Zone Livelihood Support and Partnership Programme, approved in September 2004, and expand its geographical area to cover large parts of the tsunami-affected areas.
  • Proceed with inception, formulation and appraisal of a new Coastal Resources Management Programme to cover most of the coastal zones of the country, which would be in line with the 2003 Country Strategic Opportunities Paper for Sri Lanka , focusing on fisheries resource management for coastal communities.
  • Explore potential partnerships with FAO and UNDP to design the intervention.
  • Design a large country grant for Sri Lanka dealing with land tenure issues and other policy issues that emerged as a result of the tsunami disaster.

IFAD has earmarked a total of about US$34.5 million for these activities, of which US$1.5 million will be in the form of grants and US$33 million will be in loans.

Back to top


Thailand

"The Moken, who have lived in isolation on South Surin Island in Thailand , emerged from the tsunami almost unscathed. The Moken are animists who believe that the sea, their island and all objects have spirits, and the Moken use totem poles to communicate with them. ‘I had never seen such a low tide,' said Salama, the Chief of the Moken. ‘I started telling people that a wave was coming.'
The Thai politicians have called for preserving their way of life and spreading their long-held wisdom."
Abby Goodnough, New York Times, quoted in the International Herald Tribune, 24 January 2005

The tsunami affected the southern provinces of Thailand including Phuket, Ranong, Phang-Nga, Krabi, Trang and Satun. The impact, as reported by FAO and WHO, includes:

  • 5,303 dead
  • about 800 hectares of land affected by floods
  • about 54,000 livestock killed
  • about 5,264 fishing boats damaged or totally wrecked, of which 75 per cent were small-scale fishing boats
  • about 300,000 fishermen may have lost their jobs
  • seafood supplies down by 90 per cent in some affected areas

IFAD's response:

  • Identify alternative livelihood opportunities for coastal fisherfolk who lost their boats, but who would be willing to take other opportunities for employment and income generation.
  • Explore possibilities for partnership with other key agencies and organizations active in the country, such as FAO.
  • Provide grants to support analysis of policy issues emerging after the disaster.

Back to top


Malaysia and Myanmar

The damage in Malaysia and Myanmar was minimal and far less than in other Asian countries. IFAD therefore will not be directly involved in development activities in these countries. However, IFAD is considering the inclusion of both countries in an IFAD regional grant-funded initiative.

Back to top


Tsunami raises land rights questions

As a part of its development assistance to the tsunami-affected areas, IFAD is also exploring possibilities of partnership with the International Land Coalition (ILC). Hosted at IFAD, the ILC is an alliance of intergovernmental agencies, governments and civil society organizations and focuses on access to land for poor men and women.

IFAD and ILC would work together to address issues such as land tenure and inclusion of the tsunami-affected communities in the decision-making process.

The following issues have been identified:

  • Usufruct rights of people who rely on coastal access for fishing or fish processing should be identified and retained.
  • Alternative means to claim user and ownership rights need to be developed, as some people have lost citizenship and other official documents.
  • Land rights need to be secured for women who have lost their husbands and are now heads of households.
  • Application of laws and regulations needs to ensure that the rights of poor people are protected in order to prevent land appropriation, particularly by powerful interests.
  • Future inheritance rights for children who lost their parents need to be ensured.
  • In cases where there are no family survivors, unclaimed land should be identified and used to improve the livelihoods of landless families.
  • Security of tenure needs to be established for people whose land rights before the tsunami were insecure.
  • Community-based mapping and dispute resolution can be used to identify pre-existing rights and address tenure conflicts.
  • Civil society organizations working directly with affected communities often have valuable knowledge of traditional land rights and emerging tenure-related issues. They should be considered as development partners .

Common resources such as mangroves and shorelines need to be restored and stabilized in the wider environmental and economic interest, while maintaining access by poor households, which rely heavily on common property for their livelihoods. Well-defined rights would provide the tsunami-affected communities with incentives to protect these natural resources for a more sustainable future.

Back to top


 

 

 


Contact

[email protected]
www.ifad.org

Martina Spisiakova
Tel: 3906-54592295

About IFAD

The International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) is a specialized agency of the United Nations, dedicated to eradicating poverty and hunger in developing countries. Its work in remote rural areas of the world helps countries achieve the Millennium Development Goals. Through low-interest loans and grants, IFAD develops and finances projects that enable rural poor people to overcome poverty themselves.

IFAD tackles poverty not just as a lender, but as an advocate for the small farmers, herders, fisherfolk, landless workers, artisans and indigenous peoples who live in rural areas and represent 75 per cent of the world’s 1.2 billion extremely poor people. IFAD works with governments, donors, non-governmental organizations, local communities and many other partners to fight the underlying causes of rural poverty. It acts as a catalyst, bringing together partners, resources, knowledge and policies that create the conditions in which rural poor people can increase agricultural productivity, as well as seek out other options for earning income.

IFAD-supported rural development programmes and projects increase rural poor people’s access to financial services, markets, technology, land and other natural resources.

read more

Upcoming events:

Governing Council – 16-17 February, Rome
IFAD's action plan for the Tsunami response

Useful links:

UN's response

Asian Development Bank

World Bank